Dinah's sister, Claudia, has been seeing an Englischer, and Dinah has been covering for her. She promises to keep Claudia's secret, but when Claudia disappears, everything comes out-including the lie Claudia told her family when she claimed she was being courted by local Amish boy, Aaron Burner. That particular lie burns through Dinah's heart, for she's fond of Aaron Burner; more than fond, truth be told. Aaron is disappointed that Dinah would cover her sister's lie. He's always liked Dinah, and her sister Claudia has also been a good friend. But Aaron doesn't like being used-by either Claudia or Dinah. Claudia's disappearance is one thing, but her return... That's an even bigger mess. Dinah finds herself at odds with her sister, torn between loyalty to her and her feelings for Aaron. When Claudia decides to coerce Aaron into marrying her, Dinah is beside herself. There seems to be no hope for her own happiness. How can Dinah stay and witness her sister's wedding to the man she loves?